Why Did Humans Start Farming? It Made Everything Worse
The Original Affluent Society

In 1972, American anthropologist Marshall Sahlins published an influential essay called The Original Affluent Society. His argument challenged one of the oldest assumptions about human history: that hunter-gatherers lived in constant struggle against starvation, spending practically every waking hour searching for food.
Sahlins proposed a radically different picture. Many hunter-gatherer communities could meet their basic needs in relatively few hours of work, leaving considerable time for social activities, rest, and cultural life. Their knowledge of local ecosystems allowed them to exploit a wide variety of food sources, while mobility helped them avoid exhausting resources in one location.
The idea was provocative because it reversed the conventional story of progress. If people could already feed themselves without cultivating fields, why would they voluntarily exchange a flexible lifestyle for the exhausting routine of agricultural production?
The archaeological record makes the question even more uncomfortable. Studies of Neolithic skeletons across Central and Southeastern Europe have found reduced average height and body mass compared with earlier hunter-gatherer populations. At Çatalhöyük, an early farming settlement in modern-day Turkey, researchers identified evidence of nutritional stress, increased physical demands, and widespread dental decay associated with carbohydrate-heavy diets.
Agriculture had created a more reliable supply of calories, but those calories often came from a narrow selection of crops. A diet dominated by cereals could fill stomachs while providing fewer essential nutrients than a varied diet of wild plants, meat, fish, and other foods.